Skip to content
Property Buzz
Property news

‘Blood on its hands’: Tarrant warns ATO automation is the next Robodebt

Phil Tarrant says accountants are reporting the tax office is getting automated debt notices wrong "so often", and wants transparency on how ATO staff are remunerated for collections.

Property Buzz Newsdesk 4 min read
Editorial illustration for a property news story titled "‘Blood on its hands’: Tarrant warns ATO automation is the next Robodebt". Summary: Phil Tarrant says accountants are reporting the tax office is getting automated debt notices wrong "

Illustration generated by AI for Property Buzz.

Property Buzz host Phil Tarrant has compared the Australian Taxation Office's automated small business collection activity to the Robodebt scandal, warning there will be "huge consequences" and predicting a royal commission into the current approach.

Speaking on the Property Buzz podcast, Tarrant said he had spent an hour that week with a well-known accountant who told him he had "never seen anything like it".

"Largely that the ATO is using machine learning and AI to try and chase debts and try and get as much money as they can," Tarrant said, adding that the accountant's view was that "they're just getting it wrong so often".

"The draconian tactics that they're using, the aggressiveness of it all, it's absolutely appalling the way the ATO is behaving right now."

The episode included audio of the shadow treasurer being interviewed ahead of a Senate estimates hearing on the issue. In that clip, he described the ATO sending letters to small businesses that compare single touch payroll data with super fund data.

"If there's any inconsistency, we're basically going to assume you're guilty and be prepared for up to 200 per cent fines," he said of the ATO's messaging.

"What we want to know is how is this system working? To what extent is it automated? To what extent are small businesses being deliberately targeted? And also how many people are being impacted by this and what is their expectation of revenue, because this seems like an absolute disaster."

He pointed to record small business insolvencies, rising voluntary closures and existing cash flow problems, arguing "the government is setting the ATO onto small businesses like Rottweilers because they need the revenue to feed their spending addiction".

Calls for transparency on ATO incentives

Tarrant said he wanted Senate estimates to examine how tax office staff are paid and whether collection targets feed into bonuses.

"I'd actually like to see, maybe someone the next set of estimates can actually understand how tax offices are remunerated and what bonus systems they have," he said.

"I want transparency, absolute transparency on how people are being instructed, how people are being trained and how people are being rewarded and remunerated for effective, draconian tax collection practices."

Tarrant's co-host noted that in 2018 the Inspector-General of Taxation examined allegations that ATO debt collection staff were assessed against the amount of debt they recovered, but said the allegations were not substantiated. He drew a parallel with police being incentivised on arrest numbers, calling it a conflict of interest.

Tarrant also questioned the calibre of staff at the agency. "I don't think the tax office is attracting the best and brightest people," he said. "I think the training is subpar. I think the empathy training that the tax office is getting is absolutely appalling."

He stressed he was not arguing against paying tax. "I'm not saying that Australians shouldn't pay their tax, by the way, but the way in which the ATO is chasing tax bills and the inaccuracy of it as a result of a lot of automation and other technology they're using, which isn't up to speed, there's going to be huge consequences."

Mental health warning

Tarrant repeated a claim he said he first made about a month earlier, that the government "will have blood on its hands" as a result of the collection regime, and said he expected a royal commission in time.

He referenced a statistic that 35 per cent of small business owners have mental health challenges as a result of the economy, and urged listeners to check in on business owners in their networks.

"If you are concerned or worried about people, or you're in a [bad place] yourself, Lifeline, don't be scared to call these numbers if you need some help," he said, also pointing to the Small Business Ombudsman as a source of support.

The podcast also noted reports of several hundred million dollars being spent on refurbishing ATO offices in Canberra, with Tarrant saying the total figure he had seen was in the order of a quarter of a billion dollars including rent and moving costs.

Listen to the full episode: Another Robodebt? Behind the ATO’s automated small business crackdown

Every weekday, 6am

Get the Daily Brief

One page. Everything that moved Australian property overnight, with links straight to the source.

Subscribe free

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.